Not a Chain

Local businesses, no chains · Updated October 2026

The insurance brokers of Melbourne

As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated local insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC on Not a Chain, with chains left out, are ProTrades Insurance (5.0 from 51 Google reviews), Tony Insurance (5.0 from 49 Google reviews) and McKenzie Ross Business Insurance Brokers (4.9 from 109 Google reviews).

Insurance Brokers compared
56
Google reviews
3,130
Median rating
4.9

The insurance brokers of Melbourne: the top 30

  4. 4

    Global Insurance Solutions

    5.0 from 24 Google reviews.

    Level 3, Building 7, Botanicca Corporate Park, 570/588 Swan St

    globalinsurancesolutions.com.au

  9. 9

    Axle Insurance Brokers

    5.0 from 7 Google reviews.

    Botannica Corporate Park, Level 3, Building 7/570-588 Swan St

    axleinsurance.com.au

  14. 14

    Benjamin & Benjamin Insurance Group

    5.0 from 5 Google reviews.

    198 Harbour Espl, Melbourne VIC 3008

    benjamin-ig.com.au

  20. 20

    Lifebroker

    4.6 from 66 Google reviews.

    390 La Trobe St, Melbourne VIC 3000

    lifebroker.com.au

  21. 21

    Yes Insurance Group

    4.5 from 162 Google reviews.

    222 Kings Way, Melbourne VIC 3205

    yesinsurance.com.au

  24. 24

    Swann Insurance

    4.4 from 634 Google reviews.

    181 William Street, Melbourne VIC 3000

    swanninsurance.com.au

  25. 25

    1300 Insurance

    3.7 from 7 Google reviews.

    101 Collins St, Melbourne VIC 3000

    1300insurance.com.au

  27. 27

    iSelect

    4.0 from 693 Google reviews.

    Level 11, Tower 1/727 Collins St

    iselect.com.au

  28. 28

    Master Builders Insurance Brokers

    3.3 from 12 Google reviews.

    mbib.com.au

  29. 29

    Famous Insurance

    3.5 from 40 Google reviews.

    BJS Insurance Brokers, 600 St Kilda Rd, Melbourne VIC 3004

    famousinsurance.com.au

  30. 30

    Victorian Managed Insurance Authority

    2.1 from 83 Google reviews.

    vmia.vic.gov.au

Not a Chain compared 56 insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC, with 3,130 Google reviews between them. Of these, 30 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.9 from a median of 7 reviews.

Of the insurance brokers compared, the most reviewed is iSelect, with 693 Google reviews at 4.0.

How this list is ranked

Businesses are ranked as in the fairly rated method, but only those whose name and website each appear in no more than two places in Australia are listed, so chains and franchises are left out. Each needs at least five Google reviews.

A business that shares its name with unrelated businesses elsewhere can be left out by mistake, and being part of a chain says nothing about quality.

The whole method and its rules

Questions

Which local insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC, not chains, are the most fairly rated?
As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated local insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC on Not a Chain, with chains left out, are ProTrades Insurance (5.0 from 51 Google reviews), Tony Insurance (5.0 from 49 Google reviews) and McKenzie Ross Business Insurance Brokers (4.9 from 109 Google reviews).
How does Not a Chain rank insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC?
Businesses are ranked as in the fairly rated method, but only those whose name and website each appear in no more than two places in Australia are listed, so chains and franchises are left out. Each needs at least five Google reviews. A business that shares its name with unrelated businesses elsewhere can be left out by mistake, and being part of a chain says nothing about quality.
How many insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC did Not a Chain compare?
Not a Chain compared 56 insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC, with 3,130 Google reviews between them. Of these, 30 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.9 from a median of 7 reviews.
Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.

Insurance Brokers elsewhere

More in Melbourne