1
Choicey
from 345 Google reviews.
Local businesses, no chains · Updated October 2026
The insurance brokers of Victoria
As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated local insurance brokers in Victoria on Not a Chain, with chains left out, are Choicey (5.0 from 345 Google reviews), CGIB - Commerical and General Insurance Brokers (5.0 from 237 Google reviews) and 3Point Insurance (5.0 from 162 Google reviews).
- Insurance Brokers compared
- 329
- Google reviews
- 11,562
- Median rating
- 5.0
The insurance brokers of Victoria: the top 50
2
CGIB - Commerical and General Insurance Brokers
from 237 Google reviews.
3
3Point Insurance
from 162 Google reviews.
4
National Motor Claims
from 141 Google reviews.
5
GT Insurance Brokers Bendigo
from 130 Google reviews.
43 Williamson Street, Bendigo VIC 3550
6
Lesure Insurance Solutions
from 119 Google reviews.
7
Megalines Insurance & Risk Advisers
from 118 Google reviews.
22-30 Wallace Ave, Melbourne VIC 3030
8
My Motor Claim
from 118 Google reviews.
9
Stone Lane Broking & Risk Advisory
from 104 Google reviews.
395 Nepean Hwy, Melbourne VIC 3199
10
Co-Pilot Finance & Insurance
from 92 Google reviews.
11
FD Beck Insurance Brokers
from 90 Google reviews.
18/296 Bay Road, Cheltenham VIC 3192
12
Tudor Insurance Australia
from 83 Google reviews.
52 Old Princes Hwy, Melbourne VIC 3807
13
Planet Wealth - Financial Advisers Melbourne
from 77 Google reviews.
14
Atlas Broker
from 76 Google reviews.
50 New St, Melbourne VIC 3134
15
Biima Insurance Brokers
from 67 Google reviews.
16
iLink Insurance Brokers
from 67 Google reviews.
17
Graham Lyle Insurance
from 58 Google reviews.
18
Informed Insurance
from 52 Google reviews.
19
ProTrades Insurance
from 51 Google reviews.
20
Earnest Insurance Brokers
from 50 Google reviews.
21
Tony Insurance
from 49 Google reviews.
101 Collins St, Melbourne VIC 3000
22
My Insurance Specialist Pty Ltd
from 46 Google reviews.
23
Insurance Me Advisory
from 41 Google reviews.
24
CoverTradie
from 40 Google reviews.
25
Smart Business Insurance Pty Ltd.
from 900 Google reviews.
Level 3, 9-11 Claremont Street, South Yarra VIC 3141
26
Procella Insurance Solutions
from 37 Google reviews.
27
AMC Insurance Brokers
from 36 Google reviews.
28
McGregor Insurance & Advisory
from 36 Google reviews.
29
Reliant Business Insurance
from 34 Google reviews.
24 Patricia Loop, Keysborough VIC 3173
30
Essential Insurance Solutions Pty Ltd
from 33 Google reviews.
31
Pindara Insurance Advisers
from 33 Google reviews.
32
Tempo Insurance Group
from 29 Google reviews.
33
Angel Insurance Brokers | public Liability | Transport & Logistics | Commercial Property | Professional Indemnity |
from 125 Google reviews.
34
McKenzie Ross Business Insurance Brokers
from 109 Google reviews.
501 La Trobe St, Melbourne VIC 3000
35
Global Insurance Solutions
from 24 Google reviews.
Level 3, Building 7, Botanicca Corporate Park, 570/588 Swan St
36
MeyerInsure
from 23 Google reviews.
37
Yana Glogal Services
from 59 Google reviews.
5 Tavor St, Melbourne VIC 3029
38
Fundamental Insurance Brokers Melbourne
from 58 Google reviews.
230 Collins St, Melbourne VIC 3000
39
Serendipity Insurance
from 20 Google reviews.
40
Capital Means
from 19 Google reviews.
41
JBHK Mortgage & Insurance Services
from 19 Google reviews.
42
Spectrum Insurance Group
from 18 Google reviews.
43
Macedon Ranges Insurance
from 17 Google reviews.
44
Community Insurance Solutions
from 35 Google reviews.
172-176 McIvor Highway, Strathdale VIC 3550
45
BJS Insurance Brokers (Mornington)
from 16 Google reviews.
Ste 6, Level 1/315 Main St
46
image insurance
from 16 Google reviews.
47
Sheppard Insurance Advisers - SIA
from 16 Google reviews.
48
McCormick Harris Insurance
from 31 Google reviews.
422 Hargreaves St, Bendigo VIC 3550
49
Arcuri & Associates Insurance Professionals
from 15 Google reviews.
50
Martial Arts Australia Insurance Services
from 15 Google reviews.
Not a Chain compared 329 insurance brokers in Victoria, with 11,562 Google reviews between them. Of these, 152 meet this list's method. The median rating is 5.0 from a median of 8 reviews.
Of the insurance brokers compared, the most reviewed is Smart Business Insurance Pty Ltd., with 900 Google reviews at 4.9.
How this list is ranked
Businesses are ranked as in the fairly rated method, but only those whose name and website each appear in no more than two places in Australia are listed, so chains and franchises are left out. Each needs at least five Google reviews.
A business that shares its name with unrelated businesses elsewhere can be left out by mistake, and being part of a chain says nothing about quality.
Questions
- Which local insurance brokers in Victoria, not chains, are the most fairly rated?
- As of October 2026, the three most fairly rated local insurance brokers in Victoria on Not a Chain, with chains left out, are Choicey (5.0 from 345 Google reviews), CGIB - Commerical and General Insurance Brokers (5.0 from 237 Google reviews) and 3Point Insurance (5.0 from 162 Google reviews).
- How does Not a Chain rank insurance brokers in Victoria?
- Businesses are ranked as in the fairly rated method, but only those whose name and website each appear in no more than two places in Australia are listed, so chains and franchises are left out. Each needs at least five Google reviews. A business that shares its name with unrelated businesses elsewhere can be left out by mistake, and being part of a chain says nothing about quality.
- How many insurance brokers in Victoria did Not a Chain compare?
- Not a Chain compared 329 insurance brokers in Victoria, with 11,562 Google reviews between them. Of these, 152 meet this list's method. The median rating is 5.0 from a median of 8 reviews.
- Can a business pay to be listed or to rank higher?
- No. Every business is ranked by the same published method, and no business can pay to be listed or to move up.